Today marks the triumphant return of the Mendota Beacon across campus. Running of the paper has moved to new hands and I've moved up to the position of 'village elder.' After running it day-to-day in the spring, moving back to a role of mainly just contributing articles is a welcome relief. As the paper is still getting its internet kinks out, I'll stoop to some shameless self-promotion.As students return to campus to start class, our student leaders are forming new ideas and goals to attempt to achieve this school year. One idea that's floating around this year is to start up an ASM grocery store.
I agree that for as populated as the University area is, there seems to be a shortage of grocers—take the University with 40,000 students in comparison to my small home town which has five thousand residents and one full grocery store—but I don’t believe ASM should use our money in an attempt to fix the perceived problem.
Students don’t have the same consumer needs as average people living in families. The students in dorms are the least able to easily get to a store, but that’s overlooking the fact that the few thousand people who live in dorms have their food needs served by cafeterias. Food service also takes care of the other typical things they eat—snacks, munchies, and microwavables—with small convenience stores adjacent to the cafeterias.
There is one grocery store by State Street this side of the Capitol. I’ve heard complaints about it, including high prices. However if that store is making such a killing as a monopoly, then the market would have taken care of it already by someone else realizing it and starting up his own store to get a slice of the student money. However, everything from Madison’s anti-business laws to land zoning laws are deterrents holding up the market that wants to serve us as consumers, but that’s a different story.
Even students who live on the outside without cars, have another means of getting somewhere: the bus, for free with their ASM bus passes. Sure, it’s not the most time-efficient or easy way to go, but it beats walking. On the bus maps, they even label where the numerous grocery stores are! People complain about having to spend hours on the bus venturing to the edge of town, overlooking a grocery store just a mile south of campus on Park Street.
A problem for ASM, as it seeks an affirmation of its existence in starting up a student supermarket, is that if it could be done profitably serving the student areas, then a store or two would have opened already. From the start, they’re going to be trying to sail a sinking ship. Not to mention that running a grocery store is more complicated than providing a non-perishable service, since grocers normally buy goods, mark them up a little, and then hope to sell them before they spoil. Luckily for them, ASM gets hundreds of dollars from each of us each semester that could be put toward a failing enterprise.
In recent newspaper articles, I’ve read that some people would like to put the store in the new Union South or in the new University Square building. I, too, last year imagined a grocery store going into the new retail space in University Square, but we students can’t force a business into a private development, something we don’t own. Moreover, our campus is simply too big for a single store to be convenient to a majority of students. People on the east side of campus rarely venture out to Union South as it is, let alone carrying groceries, and visa versa from the western side.
I don’t complain about something without providing a suggestion. My idea is that if they want to start a grocery store, it should be for-profit, or at the least setup as some kind of co-op. To give it as big a market as possible and taking into consideration easy access and rentable places, it should be on or near Regent Street, so students and Madisonians alike would shop there. While not close to the State Street area, numerous buses, even the 85, run along Regent and Park Streets up towards the Capitol. If it doesn’t catch, after a year or so, it’d just close and ASM would be out its check. If it works well, I would hope to see its profits either re-invested or go directly to ASM to help pay down the amount we students need to pay in seg fees.
All in all, a campus grocery store would be convenient for some people, yet all students would bear its cost equally. At present there are other issues ASM could be dealing with, especially as the students’ advocate for city safety.
Labels: ASM, Beacon, food, Free Market, university
|